Examine the newspaper in the bleeding room.
Examine the Newspaper in the bathroom on the top floor.
After you examine the newspaper, the door will close and the room will fill with smoke. Destroy the door to free yourself from the room.
Head to the basement and examine the Strange Candle.
Lastly examine Carrie’s Will.
Head to the back side of the house and examine the Gravestone.
After you click the tombstone, an urn will appear along with several purple glowing orbs in the shape of a star. The pattern to collect the Urn safely is to follow the purple orbs in the same direction that they spawn. From where I am standing in the picture, the correct order is: Bottom Right, Top Left, Top Right, Bottom Left, Top Center.
If you do not have the urn spawn after clicking on the gravestone, the quest is bugged in your instance. You must either be invited to another instance where it is working, or have a GM complete the quest for you.